How to Go From Being The Best
To The Best Ever!
A practical Mental Performance Mastery system
for sustaining excellence after success
The Dangerous Moment After Success
Everybody wants to be the best: the best player, the best team, the best coach, or the best in the country. Yet one of the most dangerous moments in a performer’s career is the moment they finally get there.
Success can create a feeling of arrival. The habits that produced the result begin to feel optional. The athlete shifts from pursuing growth to protecting status. The scoreboard says they won, but the daily standard quietly slips.
That is why there is a massive difference between being the best and becoming the best ever. Being the best is an outcome. Becoming the best ever is a standard.
Being the best means you reached the top of the mountain. Becoming the best ever means you understand that you do not get to live there. You celebrate the summit, learn from it, come back down, build a new plan, and start climbing again.
The race to excellence has no finish line. The moment you think you have arrived is the moment you begin to decline.
Best Is an Outcome. Best Ever Is an Operating System.
A scoreboard tells you what happened today. A standard tells you who you are committed to becoming every day.
When an athlete’s identity is built only on winning, success can make that athlete fragile. Now there is something to protect: a ranking, a record, a role, or a reputation. Attention moves toward the people chasing them. Preparation becomes defensive.
When identity is built on a standard, the athlete stays on offense. The questions change:
Did I live the standard today?
Did I prepare like the person I say I want to become?
Did I compete with courage?
Did I make the people around me better?
The best performers do not lower the standard because they won. They raise it because winning revealed what is possible.
This is Pillar 1, Elite Mindset. An elite mindset is not pretending everything is easy. It is a growth perspective that says, “I am responsible for my response, and there is always another level.” The best say, “I proved it.” The best ever say, “Now I have to prove it to myself again today.”
Georges St-Pierre: Don’t Waste the Loss
Georges St-Pierre is one of the greatest athletes I have ever had the privilege to work with. Most people know GSP for the championships, title defenses, discipline, and professionalism. But greatness is never the whole story.
When Georges lost to Matt Serra in one of the biggest upsets in UFC history, that result could have become an identity. It could have been a brick he carried into every future fight.
Instead, Georges changed his relationship with the event. The loss was painful, but his response was still his. He began to see it as feedback. It exposed where he had drifted and reminded him that talent does not protect anyone from a lapse in preparation, focus, or respect for the process. He eventually described the loss as one of the best things that happened to him because of what it taught him.
Average performers ask, “What does this result say about me?” Elite performers ask, “What can this result teach me?” People with a chance to become the best ever ask, “How can I use this to become more?”
Georges did not become great because he never lost. He became great because he refused to waste the loss. He came back more disciplined, focused, professional, and committed to the daily standard.
The 8 Mindset Shifts That Sustain Excellence
The movement from best to best ever is not one mental trick. It is a set of shifts that activate the entire Mental Performance Mastery system.
- From motivation to commitment. Motivation is how you feel; commitment is what you do. After the trophy arrives, external fuel can disappear. Pillar 2 asks athletes to connect their work to a purpose bigger than applause. A revealing question is: If the trophy disappeared, would your standard remain?
- From comparison to awareness. The best ever study the competition without surrendering focus to it. Pillar 3 develops accurate self-evaluation. Use Well, Better, How: What did I do well? What can I do better? How will I improve it? When athletes rate themselves from one to ten, use the “no sevens” rule. A seven is often the safe answer. Choose a six or an eight and explain why.
- From intensity to consistency. Anybody can produce one extraordinary workout. The best ever are excellent when nobody is watching. Pillar 4, Self-Control and Discipline, is choosing the response that serves the mission rather than the mood. Pillar 7 turns discipline into routines. The goal is to do a little a lot, not a lot a little.
- From outcome obsession to process ownership. Pillar 5 does not deny that outcomes matter. It teaches that an athlete cannot execute an outcome; they can execute the behaviors that give it the best chance to happen. Process creates something useful to own today.
- From hoping to rehearsing. Pillar 6 uses mental imagery and meditation to prepare responses before pressure arrives. Athletes can rehearse the first five minutes, a bad call, fatigue, a mistake, or a late-game decision. They should also rehearse the morning after success: returning to the routine when everyone says they have made it.
- From managing time to investing energy. Pillar 8 becomes more important after success because success creates more demands. Interviews, appearances, opportunities, and requests all compete with training, recovery, sleep, relationships, and reflection. The best ever calendar priorities and protect energy.
- From personal achievement to leadership. Pillar 9 asks whether personal excellence raises the performance of others. Does the athlete’s preparation make the standard clearer? Does their response to adversity give teammates permission to respond better? Who gets better because that person is present.
- From a star to a standard that survives. Pillar 10, The Right Culture, makes excellence larger than any individual. A healthy culture knows what the standard looks like, sounds like, and feels like. It survives graduation, injuries, staff changes, and a single championship season.
Use a 5 Item Success Checklist
One of the most effective tools I have used in more than 25 years of coaching mental performance is the Success Checklist. It is a short set of controllable behaviors that define a winning day.
For an athlete pursuing sustained excellence, the checklist might include:
- Complete physical preparation with intent.
- Complete ten minutes of mental training.
- Recover with purpose.
- Have one intentional leadership interaction.
- Complete an evening reflection.
Five boxes. Clear, controllable, and repeatable.
At the end of the day, the athlete does not have to wonder whether they moved forward. The evidence is visible. The Success Checklist reconditions attention away from a distant result and back to daily execution. It helps ensure no stone is left unturned and no deed is left undone in preparation.
The checklist must be observable. “Be focused” is vague. “Phone off and one written cue before practice” is observable. “Be a leader” is vague. “Have one intentional conversation with a teammate” is observable.
The Five-Step Best-Ever Reset
When an athlete reaches the top, resist the urge to give them a bigger outcome goal immediately. First, help them build a higher operating standard.
Step 1: Celebrate and extract. Recognition, gratitude, and enjoyment matter. Celebration is a recovery station, not a permanent address. Ask what the season taught, which behaviors made the biggest difference, what almost cost the result, and what must never become optional.
Step 2: Redefine the mountain. The old summit is now part of the landscape. Ask, “Who must you become next?” The next level may be leadership, consistency, emotional control, recovery, or becoming a teammate younger athletes can follow.
Step 3: Build the five-item Success Checklist. Choose behaviors across physical preparation, mental training, recovery, organization, and leadership. Make each one specific enough that the athlete can answer yes or no.
Step 4: Schedule the review. Every week, use Well, Better, How or Start, Stop, Continue. Tell the truth without making the truth personal. The athlete is not judging their worth; they are evaluating their process.
Step 5: Create a contribution goal. Ask, “Who gets better because you are here?” The best-ever journey cannot remain only about collecting achievements. At some point, it must become about contributing to people and culture.
What This Looks Like in Sport
Imagine a pitcher who has won the biggest award in the sport. The average response is to chase more strikeouts, more wins, and another award. The Best-Ever Reset asks different questions.
Which routines allowed you to take the ball every fifth day? How will you protect them as your schedule gets busier? What part of your preparation still breaks down under stress? How will you help younger pitchers learn the standard? What response do you want ready when the first difficult start arrives?
Now the athlete is not defending a trophy. They are developing a system.
Or imagine a basketball player who has become the leading scorer. The next step may not be taking more shots. It may be organizing recovery, becoming the most reliable defensive communicator, rehearsing late-game decisions, or learning to refocus after a missed shot in one breath rather than losing three possessions.
The achievement opens the door. The operating standard determines how far the athlete goes through it.
Three Coaching Mistakes to Avoid
First, do not turn “best ever” into a comparison trap. This framework is not about arguing across eras or chasing another person’s résumé. Athletes can respect the greats without becoming consumed by somebody else’s path. Best ever is a commitment to fully develop personal potential and impact.
Second, do not confuse excellence with constant maximum intensity. The best ever know how to turn it on and turn it off. Recovery, relationships, and enjoyment are part of sustainable performance. The goal is not burnout with a trophy. It is repeatable excellence.
Third, do not confuse high standards with low compassion. Great coaching is both demanding and supportive. Tell the truth, hold the line, and separate the person’s value from the performance result. The athlete is not their last win or last loss. They are responsible for their next response.
The Seven-Day Best-Ever Audit
Use this seven-day challenge with an athlete, a staff, or an entire team:
- Day 1: Write the standard you want to represent.
- Day 2: Identify the three habits that created your current success.
- Day 3: Identify the one comfort that could create your decline.
- Day 4: Build your five-item Success Checklist.
- Day 5: Complete a ten-minute imagery session of the next challenge and your response to adversity.
- Day 6: Have one leadership conversation that raises someone else’s standard.
- Day 7: Complete Well, Better, How and set the next week’s focus.
This audit gives every pillar a place in daily behavior. It replaces vague ambition with evidence. Most importantly, it puts the athlete back in motion.
Celebrate the Win. Then Take the Next Step.
Being the best is an achievement. Becoming the best ever is a decision made again and again.
It is Pillar 1 in how you think, Pillar 2 in why you stay committed, Pillar 3 in what you notice, Pillar 4 in the response you choose, Pillar 5 in the process you own, Pillar 6 in what you rehearse, Pillar 7 in the habits you repeat, Pillar 8 in how you invest time and energy, Pillar 9 in how you lead, and Pillar 10 in the culture you leave behind.
The loss is an event. The response can become part of a legacy. The championship is an event. The professionalism that follows can become part of a legacy.
Celebrate the win. Respect the work. Raise the standard. Then take the next step.
Remember, the race to excellence has no finish line.
Your Next Step!
If you are a coach looking to master mental performance coaching, the missing link in your clients and athletes performance, join Brian’s MPM Coaches Insiders List and receive his best strategies for coaching mental performance and save $200 off his MPM Certification Course when it opens this fall.
💻 Join Brian’s MPM Coaches Certification Insiders List & Save $200
👍 Take Brian’s FREE 3 Day Coaches Mini-Course
🎤 Follow Brian’s Mental Performance Daily Podcast
